I’m Getting Testy About BS

On 5/9/2019 the Youngstown Business Journal posted a video called, “Discussing Drugs in the Workplace.” The video featured, Ruth Bowdish from On Demand Drug Testing. She said that drug use has gone up so much that if affects safety in the workplace. She claimed that drug use has cost companies $81 billion in productivity, absenteeism and higher insurance rates.

         I’ve also been hearing employers on talk radio in Youngstown, Akron, and Cleveland etc. saying they can’t find employees to pass drug tests. I wondered about the real numbers of people who are not passing drug tests. I had to look no further than an article in the Youngstown Business Journal from April 13, 2019. This article by Quest Diagnostics stated that the national average of workers who fail drug test is 4.4%. In the Mahoning and Shenango Valleys that rate is even lower at 2.55 to 3.5%. That small rate shows that these area employers calling talk radio are full of crap.

What about the claim that productivity has fallen because of workplace drug use? From 1973 to 2017, net productivity rose 77.0 percent, while the hourly pay of typical workers essentially stagnated—increasing only 12.4 percent over 44 years (after adjusting for inflation). This means that although Americans are working more productively than ever, the fruits of their labors have gone to corporate profits and those at the top.

How about that safety issue and drug testing that Ruth Bowdish talked about? That is the subject of the book, “Alcohol and Illicit Drug Use in the Workplace” by researcher Michael R. Frone Ph.D. He found that there is a lack of evidence that drug testing affects safety.

Are employers who call talk radio lying when they say they can’t get employees because job seekers can’t pass drug tests? I think the real problem is that these employers want someone to work for long hours with little benefits for next to nothing. If workers are really so hard to find why aren’t wages increasing? When will the laws of supply and demand kick in? Companies in Erie, Pa. have used the failed drug test B.S. to hire immigrants at way lower wages. Employers are just playing the victim card. It is much easier than actually examining why people don’t want to work for you.

Then we have politicians that lie about job seekers not passing drug tests. When Nikki Haley was governor of South Carolina she claimed half the applicants at a nuclear reservation in her state failed a drug test. When research on this was done it showed those failing the drug test was less than one percent. Politicians and employers trash the poor and unemployed because it makes it easier to look down on them. It’s time for the employers and politicians to stop the BS stories and reflect on their own failures to help lift all boats.

John McCutcheon: “I’m an Immigrant”

“Y all Means All”

“I now have anti-bodies to assholes after working for so many.”
Crystal Woods,



Filed under Uncategorized

6 responses to “I’m Getting Testy About BS

  1. mcamish55

    Excellent reporting Jim!!
    Sharing far & wide!

  2. Nancie Shillington

    WOW-thanks for catching me up–confess, this old retired gal, I haven’t been following the issue  as much as I should have been…remember being worried 40 or so years ago as a school principal when  we started finding drugs in school lockers–and yeah, I found some in my kids’ drawer which didn’t go down well!!!!!  BUT, fortunately, in our case, that issue passed quickly–looks like it is still sticking rond in business circles–OR NOT????  Inteersting-glad you did your research!

  3. elecpencil

    Thanks Mick!!!

  4. elecpencil

    Thanks Nancie!!! We still have a drug problem in the country. I’m just saying most people using drugs are smart enough to not seek a job and think they can pass a drug test. Instead of drugs, I wish people would get high on life. If people decide to reach out and help others I think they’d feel a high like they never have.

  5. Anonymous

    Perhaps the low figure of drugs in our valley is correct, perhaps not, I know personally two businessmen who would like to hire many more for their business, they say far too many do not pass the drug test for hire.Ohio is in the top % of drug overdose, perhaps this is like Trump fake news! Also, I know far too many young people who are not seeking work due to their addiction. I do not think we are over playing this issue, wish I was wrong.

  6. elecpencil

    Thanks for your comments! What are the businessmen you know doing to attract people to the jobs they are offering? Businessmen always feel they are offering a good deal (no matter what a pittance they pay). If jobs are going begging why aren’t employers increasing wages? I’ve met young folks cutting grass, plowing snow, babysitting and cleaning houses. They do these jobs as they earn money under the table and don’t have to pay taxes. They do these jobs because the jobs employers are offering don’t pay enough. A single mother pays so much for childcare that she can’t take a low paying job. Employers need to take a hard look at the wage they are offering instead of bashing job seekers as druggies. I suspect many employers are like conservative politicians. They want us all to believe that the unemployed are just lazy drug addicts not worth hiring. We’re suppose to believe the unemployed are rolling in cash and can afford expensive drugs. All this kind of BS trashing the poor and unemployed helps conservative politicians enact policies to harm some of the most vulnerable in our country. If we fall for this crap these employers and politicians can keep feeling smug and lofty in their pews on Sunday.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s